Delicious Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie Recipe

Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is a rich, velvety dessert that embodies the warmth and tradition of Amish baking. Known for its smooth peanut butter filling and light, flaky crust, this pie is a favorite among those who love classic, homemade sweets. Unlike traditional peanut butter pies, the Amish version has a unique depth of flavor, often featuring a luscious combination of brown sugar, creamy peanut butter, and fresh dairy ingredients.

The Amish are well known for their simple, wholesome cooking, and this pie is a perfect example of their mastery in creating rich flavors from basic pantry staples. Every bite of this pie brings a taste of nostalgia, reminiscent of homemade desserts served at family gatherings or community suppers. Its creamy texture, sweet peanut butter notes, and delicate balance of flavors make it an irresistible treat for any occasion.

Why You’ll Love This Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

There are plenty of reasons to fall in love with Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie, whether you’re a die-hard peanut butter fan or just someone who enjoys a well-made homemade dessert. This pie stands out for its irresistible taste, smooth texture, and delightful balance of sweetness. Here’s why you’ll love making—and eating—this classic treat:

Rich, Creamy Texture
One of the highlights of this pie is its silky-smooth filling. The combination of peanut butter, cream, and sugar creates a luxurious texture that melts in your mouth. Unlike some peanut butter pies that can be too thick or overly dense, this Amish version has the perfect consistency—creamy, yet light enough to enjoy without feeling heavy.
Easy to Make
You don’t need to be a professional baker to master this pie. The recipe is simple, requiring only basic kitchen skills and common ingredients. With a no-fail filling and a crust that comes together easily, even beginners can create an impressive dessert.
Perfect for Any Occasion
Whether it’s a casual weekend treat, a potluck favorite, or a special holiday dessert, this pie fits any occasion. Its rich peanut butter flavor and creamy consistency make it a crowd-pleaser, and it’s sure to be the star of any dessert table.
Nostalgic and Comforting
Amish recipes are all about tradition and homey comfort. This peanut butter cream pie has that old-fashioned charm, reminiscent of childhood memories spent in the kitchen, family gatherings, and the joy of sharing homemade treats with loved ones.
Versatile and Customizable
This pie is easy to adapt to personal preferences. Whether you want to use a graham cracker crust, add a drizzle of chocolate, or incorporate a crunchy topping, there are endless ways to customize it to your liking.
Make-Ahead Friendly
If you’re hosting an event or need to prepare in advance, this pie is perfect. It stores well in the fridge, maintaining its fresh flavor and creamy texture for days. You can make it the night before and have a ready-to-serve dessert with no last-minute stress.

What You’ll Need

Before diving into the recipe, it’s important to gather all the necessary ingredients. Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie relies on simple, high-quality components that work together to create a rich and creamy texture. Here’s what you’ll need:

For the Pie Crust:

1 ½ cups all-purpose flour
½ teaspoon salt
½ cup unsalted butter, chilled and cut into cubes
4-5 tablespoons ice water

(Alternatively, you can use a pre-made pie crust for convenience.)

For the Peanut Butter Crumbs:

½ cup creamy peanut butter
½ cup powdered sugar

For the Creamy Filling:

1 cup whole milk
1 cup heavy cream
¾ cup brown sugar
¼ cup cornstarch
¼ teaspoon salt
3 large egg yolks
2 tablespoons unsalted butter
1 teaspoon vanilla extract

For the Topping:

1 cup heavy whipping cream
2 tablespoons powdered sugar
½ teaspoon vanilla extract

These ingredients create the signature balance of sweet, nutty, and creamy flavors that make this pie unforgettable. If you’re looking to enhance the dessert further, you can consider adding a drizzle of melted chocolate or a sprinkle of chopped roasted peanuts on top for extra texture and flavor.

Did you know? The Amish are known for their “from scratch” approach to cooking, avoiding processed foods and instead relying on fresh, homegrown ingredients to create their dishes!

How to Make Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Now that we have all the ingredients, it’s time to start baking! Follow these step-by-step instructions for the perfect Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie:

Step 1: Prepare the Pie Crust

In a large mixing bowl, whisk together the flour and salt.
Add the chilled butter cubes and use a pastry cutter or your fingers to blend until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs.
Gradually add ice water, one tablespoon at a time, mixing until the dough comes together. Be careful not to overwork it.
Form the dough into a disk, wrap it in plastic, and refrigerate for at least 30 minutes.
Roll out the dough on a floured surface, then place it into a 9-inch pie pan. Trim any excess, flute the edges, and prick the bottom with a fork.
Bake at 375°F (190°C) for 12-15 minutes or until golden brown. Let cool completely.

Step 2: Make the Peanut Butter Crumbs

In a small bowl, mix the peanut butter and powdered sugar with a fork until small crumbs form. Set aside.

Step 3: Prepare the Filling

In a saucepan over medium heat, whisk together the milk, heavy cream, brown sugar, cornstarch, and salt.
In a separate bowl, whisk the egg yolks. Slowly add a few tablespoons of the warm milk mixture to the yolks to temper them.
Gradually pour the egg mixture back into the saucepan, whisking constantly.
Continue cooking until the mixture thickens (about 3-5 minutes). Remove from heat.
Stir in butter and vanilla extract, mixing until smooth.

Step 4: Assemble the Pie

Sprinkle half of the peanut butter crumbs over the cooled crust.
Pour the warm filling over the crumbs, smoothing out the top.
Sprinkle the remaining peanut butter crumbs on top of the filling.

Step 5: Prepare the Whipped Topping

In a mixing bowl, beat heavy whipping cream, powdered sugar, and vanilla extract until stiff peaks form.
Spread or pipe the whipped cream over the cooled pie.

Step 6: Chill and Serve

Refrigerate the pie for at least 3-4 hours before slicing to allow the filling to set.
Slice and enjoy!

This pie is creamy, nutty, and packed with flavor in every bite. Up next, we’ll cover the best ways to serve and store your Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie!

Serving and Storage Tips for Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Now that your Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is perfectly assembled and chilled, let’s talk about the best ways to serve and store it to maintain its fresh, creamy texture and delicious flavor.

How to Serve Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Chilled for Best Texture
- This pie is best served cold, straight from the refrigerator. The creamy peanut butter filling firms up beautifully when properly chilled, making each slice smooth and easy to cut.
- For the cleanest slices, use a sharp knife and wipe it clean after each cut.
Garnish for a Beautiful Presentation
- To enhance the look and taste, consider sprinkling extra peanut butter crumbs, drizzling melted chocolate, or adding crushed peanuts on top.
- A light dusting of cocoa powder or a swirl of caramel can also elevate the flavors.
Pairing Suggestions
- This rich, creamy pie pairs wonderfully with a cup of coffee or a glass of cold milk.
- If serving for a special occasion, consider pairing it with fresh berries to add a light, fruity contrast to the peanut butter’s richness.

How to Store Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Proper storage is essential to keep your pie fresh and delicious for as long as possible. Here’s how to do it:

Refrigeration
- Cover the pie loosely with plastic wrap or aluminum foil and store it in the refrigerator.
- It stays fresh for up to 4 days, though it’s best enjoyed within the first 2 days for maximum creaminess.
Freezing for Longer Storage
- Yes, Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie can be frozen! Here’s how:
  - Wrap individual slices in plastic wrap, then place them in an airtight container or a freezer-safe bag.
  - For best results, consume within 2 months.
- To serve, let it thaw in the refrigerator overnight. Avoid microwaving, as it may alter the texture.
Avoid These Common Storage Mistakes
- Don’t leave it at room temperature for too long. The dairy-based filling needs to stay cold to maintain its consistency and prevent spoilage.
- Avoid storing it uncovered. This pie can absorb odors from the fridge, so always cover it well to keep its fresh, peanut buttery aroma intact.

By following these storage tips, you can enjoy your Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie for days without losing its creamy texture and rich flavor!

Mistakes to Avoid for Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Even though this pie is relatively simple to make, there are a few common mistakes that could impact the final result. Here’s what to watch out for to ensure your Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie turns out perfect every time.

1. Using the Wrong Peanut Butter

Avoid using natural peanut butter that separates easily. The extra oil can make the filling too loose and prevent it from setting properly.
Stick to creamy, no-stir peanut butter for a smoother, more consistent texture.

2. Not Tempering the Eggs Correctly

Adding eggs directly to hot milk can cause them to scramble, leaving you with a lumpy filling.
Always temper the eggs by slowly adding a few tablespoons of warm milk to them before incorporating them into the mixture.

3. Overcooking or Undercooking the Filling

The custard-like filling should be thickened properly, but not overheated.
If it’s too runny, it likely needs more time to cook. If it’s too thick, it may have been overcooked, leading to a pasty consistency.
Stir continuously and remove from heat once it coats the back of a spoon for the perfect texture.

4. Not Letting the Pie Chill Properly

Skipping the chilling step can lead to a runny filling when slicing the pie.
Make sure to refrigerate the pie for at least 3-4 hours, or overnight for the best consistency.

5. Whipping the Cream Incorrectly

If the whipped topping isn’t fluffy enough, it might be due to under-whipping.
On the other hand, over-whipping can turn the cream into butter, so stop once soft peaks form.

6. Rushing the Crust Preparation

If the crust is too tough or crumbly, it may have been overworked.
Handle the dough gently and let it chill before rolling it out for a flakier texture.

By avoiding these common pitfalls, you’ll ensure your Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie comes out creamy, smooth, and absolutely delicious every single time!

Tips and Tricks

When making Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie, a few simple tips and tricks can elevate your pie-making skills and ensure a flawless result every time. Here’s what I recommend for an extra touch of perfection!

1. Choose High-Quality Ingredients

For a pie that’s as rich and creamy as possible, the quality of your ingredients really matters. Opt for fresh, organic heavy cream, whole milk, and real butter to achieve that silky, smooth texture. Even the peanut butter should be of good quality; stick to smooth peanut butter with minimal added sugar for the best flavor.

2. Chill the Dough and Filling

Patience is key! Chilling both the pie dough and filling ensures that they set correctly, leading to a smoother, creamier pie. The dough should rest in the fridge for at least 30 minutes, while the filling should cool completely before you pour it into the crust. This also helps prevent the crust from getting soggy.

3. Use a Pre-baked Crust

If you’re using a store-bought crust, opt for a pre-baked graham cracker or shortbread crust for added flavor and texture. While making your own crust from scratch is traditional and tasty, a pre-baked crust can save you time, especially if you’re making the pie for a special event or last-minute gathering.

4. Don’t Skimp on Whipped Cream

The fluffy whipped cream topping is a quintessential part of this pie, so make sure to whip it until it forms stiff peaks. This ensures it will hold its shape when you serve it and add that perfect finishing touch to each slice. For an added touch, sprinkle some cocoa powder or chopped nuts on top for a visual pop.

5. Give it Time to Set

Though it might be tempting to dig into this creamy pie right away, giving it time to set in the fridge is essential. Chilling the pie for at least 3-4 hours allows the filling to firm up and the flavors to meld.

6. Use a Sharp Knife for Slicing

The smoother the slice, the better the presentation. A sharp knife ensures clean cuts through the whipped cream and peanut butter filling. After each slice, be sure to wipe the knife clean for perfect results.

By following these helpful tips, you’ll be able to make the perfect Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie with ease, every single time.

Suggestions

While the classic Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is a true crowd-pleaser on its own, there are plenty of ways to personalize the pie and make it your own! Here are a few fun variations and serving suggestions to inspire you.

Unleash your inner chef with this recipe.

1. Add a Chocolate Drizzle

Chocolate and peanut butter are a match made in heaven, so why not enhance the flavor by adding a drizzle of melted chocolate over the top of your pie? You can use either dark or milk chocolate for a more decadent finish. Simply melt chocolate and drizzle it over the whipped cream before serving.

2. Try Different Crust Options

Though the traditional pie crust is delicious, you can switch it up by using different kinds of crusts. Here are some ideas:

Graham cracker crust – for a slightly different texture and flavor, a graham cracker crust adds a nice crunch.
Oreos or chocolate cookies – crushed cookies create a chocolatey base that complements the peanut butter filling.
Shortbread crust – for a buttery and crumbly base that balances the creaminess of the pie filling.

3. Add Some Extra Nuts

For an added crunch and texture, consider chopping up some roasted peanuts or adding a sprinkling of chopped almonds on top of your whipped cream. The nutty flavor will enhance the peanut butter filling and give the pie a delightful bite.

4. Try Mini Pies

Instead of making one large pie, you can create individual mini pies in tart pans or muffin tins. This is a great option if you’re serving a crowd or want to make personal-sized treats. Just be sure to adjust the baking time for the crust if you’re making smaller portions.

5. Peanut Butter and Banana Combo

For a playful twist, try adding sliced bananas in between the layers of peanut butter filling and crust. The sweetness of the bananas pairs wonderfully with the rich peanut butter, making this pie even more indulgent.

6. Serve with a Scoop of Ice Cream

If you’re feeling extra indulgent, serve each slice with a scoop of vanilla or chocolate ice cream on the side. The cold, creamy texture of ice cream balances out the richness of the pie, creating the ultimate dessert experience.

These suggestions allow you to customize the pie based on your preferences or the occasion, making Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie even more irresistible.

FAQ

To ensure you have all the answers you need before making your Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie, we’ve compiled a list of frequently asked questions. These will help clear up any doubts and ensure you have a smooth, successful baking experience.

Explore our easy-to-make recipes now!

1. Can I make Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie ahead of time?

Yes! This pie is perfect for making ahead of time. In fact, letting it chill in the fridge for a few hours (or overnight) will help the flavors meld together beautifully. You can easily prepare the filling and crust a day or two in advance, then assemble and chill the pie when you’re ready to serve it.

2. Can I use crunchy peanut butter instead of creamy?

Yes, you can absolutely use crunchy peanut butter if you like a bit of texture in your pie. However, keep in mind that it will change the smooth, velvety texture of the filling. If you prefer a smooth finish, it’s best to stick with creamy peanut butter.

3. How long will the pie stay fresh?

The pie will stay fresh in the refrigerator for up to 4 days when properly stored in an airtight container. If you freeze individual slices, they will stay fresh for up to 2 months. Just be sure to thaw the pie in the fridge overnight before serving.

4. Can I use a store-bought crust?

Yes, you can definitely use a store-bought graham cracker crust or pre-baked shortbread crust to save time. However, if you have the time and enjoy the process, making your own homemade crust is highly recommended for the best taste and texture.

5. Can I freeze Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie?

Absolutely! You can freeze slices of the pie or the entire pie. Wrap it tightly in plastic wrap and place it in a freezer-safe container. When ready to serve, thaw it in the refrigerator for 24 hours for the best results.

6. Is there an alternative to whipped cream for the topping?

If you’re looking for a lighter option, you can substitute whipped coconut cream for the regular whipped cream. For a richer topping, you can use cream cheese frosting or even a chocolate ganache if you want to enhance the pie’s decadence.

These FAQs should help you navigate any questions that come up as you make your pie. If you have any other inquiries, feel free to reach out!

Conclusion

Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is the perfect dessert for anyone who loves the irresistible combination of peanut butter and a rich, creamy filling. Whether you’re serving it for a special occasion or simply as a treat for your family, this pie is sure to delight every time.

Discover more delicious desserts here!

With its simple yet luxurious ingredients and easy preparation, it’s a great option for both beginner and seasoned bakers alike. Follow the tips and tricks shared in this post, and you’ll have a pie that looks as amazing as it tastes. From the crust to the whipped topping, every bite is filled with creamy peanut butter goodness that’s bound to be a crowd favorite.

So, whether you’re making it ahead of time for a party, enjoying a slice with a cup of coffee, or freezing it for later, this Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is a dessert that’s sure to impress!